EFFECTIVENESS OF CRIMINAL FINES ON ILLEGAL FISHING CRIMINAL ACTIONS BY FOREIGN FISHING VESSELS (KIA) IN THE WATERS OF THE INDONESIAN EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE (ZEEI) OF THE MALACCA STRAIT (STUDY OF DECISIONS IN THE MEDAN DISTRICT COURT, CLASS 1A SPECIAL)
Keywords:
Illegal Fishing, Criminal Fines, Indonesian Exclusive Economic Zone, Fisheries CourtAbstract
This study aims to analyze the effectiveness of the application of criminal fines against perpetrators of illegal fishing by Foreign Fishing Vessels (KIA) in the waters of the Indonesian Exclusive Economic Zone (ZEEI) of the Malacca Strait based on a study of the decision of the Medan District Court Class 1A Special Fisheries Court. Indonesia as an archipelagic country has a wealth of fishery resources that are vulnerable to illegal fishing practices, especially by foreign-flagged KIA. In the international maritime law regime (UNCLOS 1982), coastal states such as Indonesia have sovereign rights to enforce the law in the ZEEI, but are limited by the prohibition on the application of imprisonment to foreign violators. Therefore, criminal fines are the main alternative in law enforcement.
The results of the study show that of the 137 fisheries crime cases decided during the period 2015–May 2025, 66 cases involved KIA with the majority being sentenced to fines and confiscation of evidence. The effectiveness of fines is shown by the significant decline in the trend of cases in the last five years, as well as the deterrent effect on foreign perpetrators. However, challenges are still found related to the success of fine recovery and coordination between law enforcers. This study confirms that although fines have not been fully optimal in their implementation, they have substantively been able to contribute to the protection of fishery resources and Indonesia's legal sovereignty at sea. Consistent law enforcement and increasing the capacity of fisheries courts are absolute requirements in strengthening the national maritime supervision and justice regime.
Downloads
References
Anwar, Yohny, T Riza Zarzani, and Chermanto Chermanto. 2023. “LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY OF MEDICAL PHYSICIANS TOWARDS QUALITY IN RADIOLOGY OPERATIONAL PERMITS AT BHAYANGKARA HOSPITAL, BANDA ACEH.” SIBATIK JOURNAL: Scientific Journal in the Field of Social, Economic, Cultural, Technology, and Education 2 (8): 2263–82.
Anwar, Yohny, T Riza Zarzani, Firman Halawa, and TM Fauzi. 2021. “Enhancement of Legal Protection of Health Outsourced Workers in Health Law Number 36 of 2009.” Budapest International Research and Critics Institute-Journal (BIRCI-Journal) 4(3): 4685–96.
Ariyanto, Bendot. 2015. “Optimizing the Role of TNI Investigators in Enforcing the Law on Illegal Fishing in Indonesia’s Exclusive Economic Zone.” Brawijaya University.
2023. Civil Law. Widina Publisher.
Daulay, Muhammad Fauzy, T Riza Zarzani, and Henry Aspan. 2022. “The Urgency of Legal Protection for Peer To Peer (P2P) Lending Consumers in Indonesia.” RECTUM JOURNAL: Legal Review of Criminal Action Handling 4 (2): 503–15.
DJOKO, SAVITRIA. nd “LAW ENFORCEMENT ON UNREPORTED AND UNREGULATED FISHING CASES IN WEST KALIMANTAN PROVINCE BY MALAYSIAN AND THAILAND FISHERMEN.” Journal of Law, Law Study Program, Faculty of Law, Untan (Journal of Undergraduate Students, Faculty of Law), Tanjungpura University 1 (3).
Djumadin, Zainul. 2019. “Policy to Eradicating Illegal Fishing in Indonesia’s Exclusive Economic Zone in the South China Sea in 2017.” Science and Culture 41 (64).
Elvany, Ayu Izza. 2017. “Legislative Policy and Its Implementation Related to Criminal Acts in the Fisheries Sector.” Islamic University of Indonesia.
Fahrurozy, M, Redyanto Sidi, and T Riza Zarzani. 2022. "A Legal Study of Online Transportation Company Responsibility to Consumer Accident Safety." Budapest International Research and Critics Institute-Journal (BIRCI-Journal) 5(2): 8831–40.
Flora, Henny Saida, and Fatar Ferdinan Banjarnahor. 2024. “LEGAL REVIEW OF FOREIGN FLAGING FISHING VESSELS IN THE EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE THAT DO NOT HAVE A FISHING LICENSE.” JOURNAL OF LAW PROFILE, 1–11.
Gemilang, Gilang, Ismaidar Ismaidar, and T Riza Zarzani. 2024. “Corporate Criminal Liability in Money Laundering Crimes.” Innovative: Journal Of Social Science Research 4 (2): 8455–71.
Handoyo, Wuri, and Dadang Suprijatna. 2024. “Law Enforcement Efforts Against Illegal Fishing Perpetrators in the Natuna Waters, Riau Islands.” Karimah Tauhid 3 (3): 3564–82.
Indra Utama Tanjung. 2024. BASICS OF LEGAL RESEARCH METHODS. Karanganyar: CV Pustaka Dikara). https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=id&user=rToGqjUAAAAJ&cstart=20&pagesize=80&citation_for_view=rToGqjUAAAAJ:Wp0gIr-vW9MC.
Kartika, Ropita, Oksep Adhayanto, and Irwandi Syahputra. 2024. “COMPARATIVE STUDY OF REGULATION LAW ON FOREIGN FISHING VESSELS IN INDONESIAN AND MALAYSIAN LAWS AND REGULATIONS.” Raja Ali Haji Maritime University.
Kurniadi, Adhi, Rinda Noviyanti, and Anak Agung Made Sastrawan Putra. 2024. “STRATEGY FOR MONITORING ILLEGAL FISHING ACTIVITIES OF FOREIGN FISHING VESSELS IN THE MALACCAN STRAIT.” ALBACORE Journal of Marine Fisheries Research 8 (4): 343–60.
Moertiono, R Juli. 2024. “[REFERENCE BOOK] Policy on Legal Sanctions for Destruction of Evidence of Illegal Fishing.”
Muhammad, Ghulam. 2015. “Legal Study on Judges’ Considerations in Sentencing Perpetrators of Illegal Fishing Crimes by Indonesian Citizens (Decision Number: 19/Pid. P/2011/Pn-Mdn).”
NASIKHATUDDINI, SITI. 2022. “Criminal Law Enforcement Against Corporations in Illegal Fishing Crimes in Indonesia.”
Niman, Adhitya Permadi, Tofik Yanuar Chandra, and Mohamad Ismed. 2023. “Law Enforcement Against Foreign Fishermen Who Commit Illegal Fishing in Indonesia.” Perfecto: Journal of Legal Studies 1 (3): 183–90.
Ningsih, Sri Dwi Retno. 2018. “Law Enforcement Against Corporations Committing Illegal Fishing Crimes in Riau Province.” UNS (Sebelas Maret University).
Pakasi, Delpiero, Olga Pangkerego, and Roosje Lasut. 2022. “IMPLEMENTATION OF SANCTIONS FOR SINKING FOREIGN FISHING VESSELS COMMITTED BY FISHERY CRIMES IN INDONESIA.” Lex Administratum 10 (3).
Pangestu, Arlen Tyas. nd “ILLEGAL FISHING IN INDONESIAN JURISDICTION FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW, NATIONAL LAW AND ISLAMIC LAW: ANALYSIS OF SHIP SINKING BY THE MINISTRY OF MARINE AFFAIRS AND FISHERIES IN THE PERIOD 2014-2019.” Faculty of Sharia and Law, Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University, Jakarta.
Ponamon, Drivi. 2022. “SINKING OF FOREIGN VESSELS CARRYING OUT ILLEGAL FISHING BASED ON LAW NUMBER 45 OF 2009 CONCERNING AMENDMENTS TO LAW NUMBER 31 OF 2004 CONCERNING FISHERIES.” LEX CRIMEN 11 (3).
Prastyo, Titus, Nazaki Nazaki, and Ardi Putra. 2023. “Strategy of Batam Marine and Fisheries Resources Surveillance Base in Handling Illegal Fishing in Natuna Regency.” Raja Ali Haji Maritime University.
Pratama, Aditya Ilham, Sofyan Wegi Alfariki, Isna Diana, Taufik Hidayat Hasibuan, and Ikmal Fata. 2025. “Legal Politics in Law Enforcement Against the Threat of Illegal Fishing in Indonesian Waters According to Lawrence M. Friedman.” Tana Mana Journal 6 (1): 137–52.
Risdawati, Irsyam, Marice Simarmata, Muhammad Juang Rambe, T Riza Zarzani, and Iwan Rohman Harahap. 2022. “Legal Analysis of Criminal Child with Mental Retardation (Study of Rantauprapat State Court Decision No. 18/PID. SUS/ANAK/2016/PN-RAP).” Budapest International Research and Critics Institute-Journal (BIRCI-Journal) 5 (1).
Robin, Jepry, Parasian Simanungkalit, and Anwar Sadat. 2023. “THE ROLE OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA POLICE IN ERADICATION OF ILLEGAL FISHING PRACTICES IN INDONESIAN WATERS.” Journal of Syntax Literate 8 (9).
ROSALINA, HENNY NATASHA. 2024. “RECONSTRUCTION OF INDONESIA’S EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE REGULATION AS A BASIS FOR DETERMINING THE BOUNDARIES OF THE EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE BETWEEN INDONESIA AND VIETNAM IN THE NORTH NATUNA SEA BASED ON THE VALUE OF JUSTICE.” Sultan Agung Islamic University Semarang.
Saputra, Raka Momon. 2018. “Perspective of Deterrence in the Framework of Criminal Policy of Sinking Fishing Vessels.” Indonesian Journal of Criminology 1 (1).
Sebastian, Willy. 2022. “Reconstruction of Regulation of Criminal Sanctions for Fish Theft Based on Justice Values.” Sultan Agung Islamic University (Indonesia).
Simanungkalit, Parasian. 2012. “The Ideal Punishment Model for Drug User Victims in Indonesia.” Yustisia 1 (3).
Susilowati, Nanda Pradhita. 2017. “Destruction of Foreign-Flagged Fishing Vessels Perpetrators of Fisheries Crimes in the Perspective of Due Process of Law.” Islamic University of Indonesia.
Suswoto, Suswoto, Muhammad Andri Nurfadilah, Savira Alfi Syahrin, and Eksy Puji Rahayu. 2023. “SINKING OF FOREIGN SHIPS CARRYING OUT ILLEGAL FISHING IN INDONESIAN WATERS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF INTERNATIONAL MARITIME LAW.” Qistie: Journal of Legal Studies 16 (1).
Tobing, Alex T, and Bambang Setiawan. 2020. Fisheries Court: An Effort to Eradicate IUU Fishing in Indonesia. Deepublish.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Robert Napitupulu
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
